A vintage fighter plane taking part in the Celebrate Freedom Festival air
show crashed about 75 yards away from homes in a southeast Columbia
neighborhood near Owens Field on Sunday afternoon, killing its veteran
pilot.
Officials believe that the pilot, Joe Tobul, 68, might have averted a
major disaster when he made an abrupt right turn out of formation to avoid
the residential area. The plane cut a path about 50 to 75 yards through
trees and left a trail of debris before crashing into a marshy field.
Witnesses said they saw smoke coming from the World War II-era Chance-Vought
F4U-4 Corsair plane before it crashed at 12:45 p.m., leading officials to
believe engine failure brought it down. Radio communication from the cockpit
indicated the plane lost power.
David Givens, 41, of Johnston, was watching from the edge of the runway
at Owens Field. He said Tobul turned to the left, as though he would try to
land on the runway, but then turned back to the right.
"He got about a mile from the runway, and I guess he decided he couldn't
make it," Givens said. "You could tell he intentionally tried to keep from
hitting anything. He lost a good bit of speed on that first turn."
Field officers from the Federal Aviation Administration were
investigating the accident Sunday night. The FAA will transport the plane to
the National Transportation Safety Board's office in Griffin, Ga., this
week, an NTSB spokesman said. Preliminary findings will begin appearing on
the agency's Web site this week, but a conclusion on the crash's cause will
not be available for at least a year, he said.
Greg Burke, 41, superintendent of the Hampton Crest subdivision, was one
of the first people at the scene. He said he was in a tree about a quarter
mile from the crash site watching as planes from the air show flew low above
the neighborhood.
"That maneuver all the planes were doing was not that high above the tree
lines," he said.
Burke said he saw a piece of debris falling, and seconds later, he heard
the crash and felt the ground vibrate from the impact.
The plane crashed about 75 yards south of two homes at 159 and 162 Wood
Ridge Lane, and about 1½ miles southeast of Owens Field.
Burke raced with some other people from the neighborhood to the crash
site and saw the fuel catch on fire, spewing flames and smoke about 30 feet
into the air.
They searched the site, looking to see if there was anyone they could
help until the first emergency vehicles showed up about five minutes later.
Chief John Jansen of the Columbia Fire Department said the landscape made
containing the fire difficult. Firefighters had to wade in chest-high water
and bring in a foam truck to extinguish the burning fuel. About 40
firefighters were on the scene at one point, Jansen said. The fire was
extinguished by 1:30 p.m.
After the fire was out, firefighters and Emergency Medical Service
personnel recovered Tobul's body from the wreckage.
Richland County Coroner Gary Watts said Tobul was dead at the scene. An
autopsy will be performed today.
Ken Breivik, spokesman for the Celebrate Freedom Foundation, said the
five planes were heading to the Dorn VA Medical Center for a flyover.
Tobul's son, Jim, and two grandsons were piloting three of the other planes
in the formation and witnessed the crash.
Richard Adams, 51, who was at the air show with his wife, said it looked
like something was wrong with the plane as it passed over.
"It didn't look normal when it went by," Adams said.
"The plane flew over for the last time (and) he peeled off to the right.
He was acting like he was shot or something. It was trailing smoke when it
went by.
"I saw the other planes. They were spiraling tight right over the top
over the trees. I just figured that's where one went down."
Airport officials said they did not end the festival because of the
traffic and safety concerns associated with evacuating the tens of thousands
of onlookers.
At Owens Field, there was no panic, only concern as people stopped in
their tracks to point and stare at the billowing dark gray smoke coming from
just beyond a stand of trees southeast of the airfield.
Murmurs of "it was the Corsair" rippled through the crowd as onlookers
tried to figure out what had happened.
An impromptu prayer circle formed between two World War II-era fighter
planes. About two dozen men, women and young children held hands, bowed
their heads and prayed for the safety of those on the airplane, as well as
anyone who might have been nearby on the ground.
But the show went on, both in the air and on the ground.
Vintage aircraft continued to take off, circle and buzz the airstrip,
thrilling the still-attentive crowds.
The air show had been attracting the largest crowds at the three-day
Celebrate Freedom Festival, which began Friday.
Tobul, a former Marine Corps pilot, purchased the plane he was flying in
1981 and guided it through a 10-year restoration before it took its first
flight in 1991. The plane, first built in 1945, suffered serious damage
after the restoration when it ran off the end of a runway. It rejoined the
air show circuit in 1999.
Officials said the plane appeared to be in good condition Sunday before
the crash.
The crash was the 14th at Owens Field since 1972.
Before Sunday, seven Chance Vought F4U model planes like Tobul's had
crashed since 1984, including one fatal crash in Chula Vista, Calif., in
1987 that killed two people.
Staff writers Monique Angle, Kenneth Harris,
Dan O'Mara and Dargan Richards contributed to this story.